'Medical schemes are remiss in not offering to fill the primary care needs'
Government has banned the private sector’s attempt to create a low-cost medical aid.
The decision by the Council for Medical Schemes has divided the health insurance industry.
Refilwe Moloto looks at the various points for and against the ban and speaks to Dr Brian Ruff of PPO Serve and Barry Childs of Insight Actuaries and Consultants.
These products were intended to come to market to provide lower-cost alternatives to medical scheme cover which is quite expensive and only affordable for people with higher incomes.Barry Childs - Insight Actuaries and Consultants
He highlights two key issues, one, the lack of communication and poor process embarked on by the Council.
Childs says the lack of consultation is what caused the strong reaction to the Council's decision.
These products are still active...but the registrar indicated that by 2021 he is going to stop them. So the communication and process seem to be a little back to front.Barry Childs - Insight Actuaries and Consultants
Since the announcement, the Council has been very conciliatory and engaged with the industry players in a roadshow, says Childs.
He is saying tell us what you have to say, give us your feedback, we want to make this work.Barry Childs - Insight Actuaries and Consultants
Secondly, he highlights that these products exist in a health reform environment with some uncertainty.
Childs says NHI dominates the narrative about where the country is moving regarding health reform.
But there's really no clarity on what role private sector is going to play - the role of medical schemes, the role of health insurance products, etc.Barry Childs - Insight Actuaries and Consultants
Childs believes these products should not be prohibited.
There is a place for these products. They do provide a valuable service.Barry Childs - Insight Actuaries and Consultants
But he agrees the products should be properly regulated and provide value.
Dr Brian Ruff weighs in and argues the correct perspective is to understand the role of what he terms gap products which addressed gaps in the medical scheme cover that medical schemes have done nothing about over some 20 years of regulation.
The effect of all of that has been that a combination of these gap products have been offered by these health insurers as an alternative to medical scheme membership to young and healthy people - because obviously they can underwrite and exclude people in a way that the schemes can't.Dr Brian Ruff - PPO Serve
Ruff argues that current unbalanced benefits in schemes are one of the drivers that make medical aid expensive.
In order to get basic stuff done, you need to be admitted to hospital where it costs tens times more than if it happens out of the hospital environment.Dr Brian Ruff - PPO Serve
Allowing these products then, rather than just fixing the medical scheme environment and filling in the gaps, is to have an ageing population which mean that prices go up making the problem even worse, he adds.
We're in a kind of vicious cycle.Dr Brian Ruff - PPO Serve
He says while he agrees the process could have been better managed, the proliferation of these products is not in anyone's long-term interests.
We need to be looking at better solutions.Dr Brian Ruff - PPO Serve
He says for a medical aid scheme to work it needs to include young and old, with cross-subsidies between old and sick people and young people.
You want everybody involved.Dr Brian Ruff - PPO Serve
He says these products are not regulated in that way.
So, these products are allowed to exclude older people or to market specifically to young people....they are paying out less than half the money that they are collecting and taking out large profits, none of which would be allowed in a regular medical scheme.Dr Brian Ruff - PPO Serve
But, he adds, the medical schemes are equally remiss in not offering to fill the primary care needs.
Why do you run out of your medical savings account in February?Dr Brian Ruff - PPO Serve
Take a listen to the insightful discussion below:
Tributes and condolence messages have been pouring in since the news broke.Read More
The Mother City's unique sightseeing experience has officially resumed.Read More
CapeTalk host John Maytham shares his top book picks for the week.Read More
American Olympic champ Katy Ledecky joined the #gotmilkchallenge and it was a lot of fun. She didn't spill a drop.Read More
The industry has been hard hit by the Covid-19 pandemic lockdown and it does not look like the end is in sight anytime soon.Read More
Involved in an accident you didn't cause? Third party claims don't pay out much. Wendy Knowler shares one driver's horror story.Read More
SANParks says national parks will reopen for overnight stays from next week Friday onwards.Read More
"If allowed to trade, we can’t be on the edge of our seats every time that the President is about to speak," pleads Kurt Moore.Read More
You can also buy inexpensive, certified pre-owned phones. Kieno Kammies talks to Flip Phone founder Conor Copas.Read More
Breweries in SA can't sell beer but they can sell wort, a key part of the normal beer-making process. Here's how it works.Read More
Businesswoman and social media influencer Zari Hassan scooped the One Africa award for Social Media and Business Innovation.Read More
Local sanitaryware brand, Cobra, is equipping young women with useful plumbing skills that will make them more employable.Read More
WhatsApp has launched a new feature that gives users the ability to cross-check those "viral" messages forwarded on the chat platform.Read More
It’s possible that all the games will take place in Nelspruit, says IOL sports editor John Goliath.Read More
Thabane Zulu (former DG, Human Settlements) reluctantly testified before the Zondo commission on Thursday, says eNCA’s Erin Bates.Read More
'Mr Eazi' launched the Africa Music Fund to support the continent's creative talent. Bruce Whitfield interviews Lee Kasumba.Read More
Justin Chadwick (Citrus Growers' Association) says it's all thanks to the perceived immune-boosting attraction of Vitamin C.Read More
Bruce Whitfield interviews Whitey Basson, who believes it's just not good enough for govt to say ban will be lifted but not when.Read More
Bruce Whitfield talks to MTN CFO Ralph Mupita about the reasons for the move and the company's huge profit increase.Read More
"It’s not rational to allow packed taxis, but not a glass of wine in a controlled environment," says Francois Rossouw.Read More