Streaming issues? Report here
CapeTalk logo 2017 1500 x 1500 CapeTalk logo 2017 1500 x 1500
Best of CapeTalk
22:00 - 00:00
volume_up
volume_mute

Up Next: Early Breakfast with Africa Melane
See full line-up
Best of CapeTalk
22:00 - 00:00
Home
arrow_forward
Opinion
fiber_manual_record
Local

Is it even possible to lock down townships and informal settlements, asks Prof

29 March 2020 3:33 PM
Tags:
University of Johannesburg
APARTHEID
#Covid19
social distancing
#lockdown21
South Africa's townships
Institute for the Future of Knowledge

Professor Alex Broadbent (UJ) on his argument that a one-size-fits-all approach to Covid-19 could have lethal consequences.

Professor Alex Broadbent published an article in The Conversation exploring why a one-size-fits-all approach to Covid-19 could have lethal consequences.

He questions why the advice of the World Health Organisation (WHO) is the same globally while contexts, particularly in Africa, are different.

Informal settlements in South Africa. Image: 123rf.com

The UJ Professor of Philosophy and director of the Institute for the Future of Knowledge speaks to Africa Melane on Weekend Breakfast.

He's worried about whether it's actually even possible, in fact, to lock down overcrowded townships and informal settlements.

Lockdown works great in the suburbs... But in a crowded context it's very, very hard to see how that can even work... with ten people in a single accommodation and a toilet 100 metres away...

Prof. Alex Broadbent, Director - Institute for the Future of Knowledge

But what is the alternative under the circumstances?

According to Prof. Broadbent, it's partly to come up with "slightly more reasonable restrictions".

There is in my opinion no reason to ban daily exercise, and no reason to ban the sale of cigarettes. There is no ban on drinking alcohol and yet you see soldiers smashing bottles in the streets... The ban is on the sale of alcohol.

Prof. Alex Broadbent, Director - Institute for the Future of Knowledge

I understand it's complicated, but I think it would make life a bit easier if some of the restrictions actually had a direct public health benefit and some of them simply don't seem to.

Prof. Alex Broadbent, Director - Institute for the Future of Knowledge

He believes there should be more focus too, on mental health.

We live in countries with a lot of gender-based violence; locking people up without their cigarettes in small rooms with each other is not a recipe to improve that situation.

Prof. Alex Broadbent, Director - Institute for the Future of Knowledge

Broadbent compares the restrictions imposed in China with those in effect in Europe and applies the argument to Africa.

He says regional characteristics should be taken into account - like South Africa's geographical apartheid inheritance, for instance.

In the way that apartheid designed the country, which is abhorrent... we do have substantial gaps in many places between suburbs and townships. You can lock down a suburb... it's nice and quiet... but I don't think that's the same thing at all as locking down a large township where people are going to sit in their very hot accommodation with a large number of other people.

Prof. Alex Broadbent, Director - Institute for the Future of Knowledge

It's abhorrent in itself, but in this context could be quite helpful. You can separate regions in a way that China managed to and the rest of the world - Italy in particular - has not managed to. Regional quarantine did not work in Italy while it was effective in China.

Prof. Alex Broadbent, Director - Institute for the Future of Knowledge

In a similar way we have in the whole of Africa very large rural expanses which are very sparsely populated, and then overcrowding where there is population. That's a totally different context to the context of the middle of Europe where you can really see things exploding, where you have large cities constantly intermingling with each other.

Prof. Alex Broadbent, Director - Institute for the Future of Knowledge

We can't contain the disease says the professor, but we can slow its spread and the trick is to slow the geographical spread.

Listen to Prof. Broadbent explain his argument in the audio below:


29 March 2020 3:33 PM
Tags:
University of Johannesburg
APARTHEID
#Covid19
social distancing
#lockdown21
South Africa's townships
Institute for the Future of Knowledge

More from Opinion

netflorist-haroldpng

Why NetFlorist should be congratulated for bringing back whiny Harold

11 August 2020 8:14 PM

Branding expert Andy Rice explains why NetFlorist's radio campaign is his advertising hero of the week.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Females women entrepreneurs high-five businesswomen 123rfbusiness 123rf

40% of contracts to women: 'ANC unable to issue tenders without corruption'

11 August 2020 3:04 PM

"Only politically connected women will benefit," warns DA Chief Whip Natasha Mazzone.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Shamila Batohi Cyril Rramaphosa

Why has Shamila Batohi taken no action against NPA members accused of crime?

11 August 2020 12:51 PM

"Covid-19 is being used as an excuse," says the DA’s Glynnis Breytenbach. "We must get on with it!"

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Female woman businesspeople diverse office 123rf 123rfbusiness

It’s far less risky to lend to a female entrepreneur than a male one - research

11 August 2020 9:26 AM

Studies across the world and industries consistently show women-entrepreneurs have a better risk profile, says Janeesha Perumal.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

mask-child-boy-learner-pupil-class-classroom-Covid-19-teaching-school-123rf

Send kids back to school, it’s safer for them there - SA Paediatric Association

7 August 2020 12:57 PM

"Covid-19 is going to be with us for years. On balance, it’s better for kids to be in school," says Prof Mignon McCulloch.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

cyril-acejpg

'Arrest Ace Magashule – and 1 or 2 others – then things will move fast'

6 August 2020 1:01 PM

“This is good stuff,” says Wayne Duvenage about the halting of pension payouts to government employees implicated in corruption.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

scz-0623jpg

Bantu Holomisa has an idea to remove ANC 'thieves' from power before 2024

6 August 2020 9:36 AM

"If I was President Cyril Ramaphosa, I would take these suggestions seriously," says the UDM leader Bantu Holomisa.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

afrika-tikkunjpg

SA needs 'the Madiba compassion' more than ever now, says Afrika Tikkun CEO

5 August 2020 8:54 PM

Marc Lubner on the NGO's programmes for young South Africans and how working with Nelson Mandela inspired his life's work.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Red wine white woman female funny reaction 123rf 123rflifestyle

Alcohol industry 'optimistic' that sales prohibition will soon be lifted

5 August 2020 1:15 PM

"If allowed to trade, we can’t be on the edge of our seats every time that the President is about to speak," pleads Kurt Moore.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

I love Zimbabwe 123rf 123rfAfrica

Zimbabwean lives matter! Yet, deafening silence from regional superpower SA

5 August 2020 9:37 AM

Zimbabweans are mobilising against the state’s brutal attacks, but seek regional solidarity, says Amnesty International SA.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

More from Local

beer-alcohol-brewery-bottle-cap-drinking-booze-warehouse-liquor-industry-123rf

Western Cape Premier says decision on alcohol ban 'won't be before Saturday'

11 August 2020 6:36 PM

Western Cape Premier Alan Winde says it's highly unlikely that any changes to the alcohol ban will be announced before the weekend.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

cape-point-funicular-03jpg

Cape Point restaurant, shop and funicular closed until provincial borders reopen

11 August 2020 5:49 PM

The funicular, shop and restaurant at Cape Point remain closed until government approves the reopening of interpovincial travel.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

bertha-meltzer-cape-town-mediclinicpng

Cape Town granny (103) was positive about recovering from Covid-19, says family

11 August 2020 3:47 PM

Bertha Meltzer, aged 103, is one of the oldest Covid-19 survivors in South Africa, and possibly the continent.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Females women entrepreneurs high-five businesswomen 123rfbusiness 123rf

40% of contracts to women: 'ANC unable to issue tenders without corruption'

11 August 2020 3:04 PM

"Only politically connected women will benefit," warns DA Chief Whip Natasha Mazzone.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Women using cellphones cell phone data 123rfbusiness 123rflifestyle 123rf

SA's first-ever digital census being tested

11 August 2020 1:47 PM

Risenga Maluleka, Statistician-General of Stats SA explains the new approach to census-taking.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

st-james-beach-2jpg

St James Beach bathing boxes are here to stay, but they may soon be closed off

11 August 2020 12:53 PM

City of Cape Town coastal manager Gregg Oelofse says the iconic beach huts may soon be closed off to public use.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Shamila Batohi Cyril Rramaphosa

Why has Shamila Batohi taken no action against NPA members accused of crime?

11 August 2020 12:51 PM

"Covid-19 is being used as an excuse," says the DA’s Glynnis Breytenbach. "We must get on with it!"

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

siseko-cisco-mhlana-facebbo-accountjpg

Cisco Mhlane cracked South Africans up posting this boere braai get-up

11 August 2020 12:15 PM

Cisco thought it would be fun to dress up in a safari suit for a braai in jest and never expected the photo he posted to go viral.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

dagga-weed-marijuana-joint-smoke-smoking-123rf

New dagga law – proposed quantities allowed, definition of 'private space', etc.

11 August 2020 11:32 AM

You may possess 1.2kg of dried dagga (kind of), and it’s fine to smoke in your car (kind of), says Paul-Michael Keichel.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

haji-mohamed-dawjee-picture-suppliedjpg

SA journalist describes long-haul Covid-19 symptoms after nearly two months

11 August 2020 10:57 AM

Journalist and author Haji Mohamed Dawjee describes ongoing pain, fatigue, fogginess, lack of concentration and forgetfulness.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward