'Lockdown judgment likely to be appealed, all or most of it will be overturned'
Constitutional expert, Pierre De Vos, talks to Refilwe Moloto about the implications of a North Gauteng High Court ruling that lockdown levels three and four are unconstitutional.
This was the judgment in the urgent case brought by a group called the Liberty Fighters Network.
The High Court has suspended the declaration for a period of 14 days and directed the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs, in consultation with the relevant ministers to review, amend and republish the regulations.
De Vos says when one makes such regulations even in a serious national emergency, they need to only pursue the purpose of the disaster declaration, to stop the spread of the virus, or to save lives in this case.
When they do so, they must do so in such a way as to limit the rights of individuals as little as possible while still achieving the goal.Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law expert
But the application to the specifics here is a little bit of a mess.Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law expert
De Vos says the judge, unfortunately, did not go through all the specifics but rather used a few examples.
He used a few of the more absurd things...and that means nearly all the regulations are irrational, which is not something one can do from a legal perspective. So I think the judgment is likely going to be appealed, and all or most of it will be overturned on appeal.Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law expert
He says the judgment does not go into sufficient detail.
That is an intricate discussion that would require much more engagement with the detail which did not happen unfortunately in the case.Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law expert
Judge Norman Davis also did not clarify whether the in invalidity of the regulations was retrospective or not, says De Vos.
If it is retrospective then all those arrests and the criminal records would be quashed.Pierre de Vos, Constitutional law expert
He says the fact that it was not mentioned makes it likely that the ruling is retrospective and all those breaking of regulation cases will be invalid.
The court, however, rejected the argument made that the declaration of the disaster was invalid.
There are a number of other cases still pending.
Listen to the interview below:
More people are likely to die from Covid-19-related hunger than the disease itself, warns Oxfam in its “Hunger Virus” report.Read More
Prof Mendelson says the SARS-CoV-2 antibody test is not the same as an HIV antibody test which is a far more reliable marker.Read More
This is literally a matter of life or death exclaims Bill in his TikTok video that has had over 10 million views.Read More
On Monday Groote Schuur hospital was able to discharge five patients from critical care after being treated on HFNO machines.Read More
Inventor Pam Gordon has come up with Fresh Scent Mask Freshness Spray to encourage kids to keep their masks on...Read More
"The Stormers are all getting tested," says John Goliath. "It’s fantastic that they do it, but there’s a risk involved."Read More
Financial planner Sylvia Walker shares advice on what to do if you need your payment holiday to be extended due to Covid-19.Read More
John Maytham speaks to UCT public health expert Prof. Landon Myer about the airborne transmission of coronavirus...Read More
The SA Bone Marrow Registry is encouraging those who can to register to be a bone marrow donor and potentially save a life.Read More
Traffic volumes on the N1, N2, N7 and M5 freeways were only at about 65% of normal levels by the end of June.Read More