'Govt should amend regulations to bring them in line with the Constitution'
The High Court judgment on Tuesday by Judge Norman Davies in the urgent case brought by a group called the Liberty Fighters Network, has suspended the declaration for a period of 14 days and directed the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs, in consultation with the relevant ministers to review, amend and republish the regulations.
Attorney Ulrich Roux talks to Clement Manyathela on The Midday Report about the way forward for government.
The way that I read the judgment, and there may be people who differ from me, is that we will remain in level 3 until these regulations are amended to be in line with the Constitution.Ulrich Roux, Attorney - Ulrich Roux & Associates
Roux says the government has two options going forward.
The first option is they can file an application for leave to appeal, he says, but the second option which he believes would be the more sensible one, would be to amend the regulations.
Sit down, take these 14 days, take society and the South African community into your confidence, and see if you can make a real attempt to amend the regulations to bring them in line with the Constitution.Ulrich Roux, Attorney - Ulrich Roux & Associates
He says government should take guidance from the court.
How will those who have been arrested or fined for breaking level 3 and 4 regulations, or whose businesses have been impacted by them, now be affected?
This could well have a big impact, he says.
The government does find itself in a peculiar position. If they do not amend the regulations within 14 days, and they do not successfully lodge an application for leave to appeal or obtain an extension on the 14-day period, that means that those regulations will lapse automatically.Ulrich Roux, Attorney - Ulrich Roux & Associates
This will result in the national state of disaster no longer being governed by the Disaster Management Act.
So people who have been found to be adversely affected by this Act where the regulations have been found to be unconstitutional will definitely have grounds to issue civil action against the government for damages suffered.Ulrich Roux, Attorney - Ulrich Roux & Associates
Listen to the interview below:
"I'm all for masks," US President Donald Trump now says, likening himself to the Lone Ranger.Read More
Sadsawu's Myrtle Witbooi explains many domestic workers aren't UIF registered and the direct contact number is hard to access.Read More
"I’m outside; I don’t need a mask. If you’re uncomfortable, stay at home." Sociologist Steven Robins tries to make sense of it.Read More
Prof Boulle says W Cape trend a lower, flatter trajectory that will continue for a long time but is easier on the health system.Read More
"We’ve hired people we haven’t met in person," says Karl Hammerschmidt. "There are things you can still do to impress."Read More
SIU's Kaizer Kganyago says cases involve price gouging and procurement process irregularities in the health sector.Read More
A labour lawyer says she has dealt with companies coming to terms with paying for employees home internet data for work purposes.Read More
UIF Commissioner Teboho Maruping says they are in discussions to find a way to help those still not back at work.Read More
Grades 7 and 12 are already back at school following the lockdown, grades R, 6, and 11 are set to return from Monday.Read More
In scenes reminiscent of the day alcohol sales were unbanned – you’ve got to see it – gamblers queued to try their luck.Read More