Streaming issues? Report here
Just the Hits generic 2 CapeTalk Just the Hits generic 2 CapeTalk
Just the Hits with Abongile Nzelenzele
11:00 - 15:00
volume_up
volume_mute

Up Next: Just the Hits
See full line-up
Just the Hits with Abongile Nzelenzele
11:00 - 15:00
Home
arrow_forward
Business
fiber_manual_record
Politics

British American Tobacco SA prepares for court showdown with govt on Wednesday

2 August 2020 10:42 AM
Tags:
British American Tobacco
BAT SA
cigarette ban
Tobacco Ban
Minister Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma
court battle

British American Tobacco SA (BAT SA) will be challenging the constitutionality of the tobacco ban in the Western Cape High Court.

The tobacco firm, which produces Dunhill and Lucky Strike, is one of 10 applicants set to jointly challenge the ban in court this Wednesday.

Tobacco farmers, manufacturers, and retailers are among other members of the industry joining the court bid.

The government defeated an earlier court challenge to unban cigarettes from the Fair Trade Independent Tobacco Association (Fita) in June.

RELATED: High Court dismisses Fita's legal bid to have cigarette ban overturned

Mike Evans, the lawyer representing BAT SA and others, says this legal application is not the same as Fita's failed bid.

Evans explains the crux of the legal arguments to CapeTalk host Sara-Jayne King.

Constitutionality

The applicants will argue that the tobacco ban infringes on various Constitutional rights, including the right to trade and the individual right to bodily integrity.

Evans says it's irrational that smokers are effectively prohibited from smoking cigarettes, but "they're allowed to smoke cannabis at home."

RELATED: Black tobacco farmers: We pay tax and create jobs, but SA govt is suppressing us

We've raised a series of Constitutional challenges saying that this ban infringes on a whole number of Constitutional rights.

Michael  Evans, Public Law Partner - Webber Wentzel

It infringes the right to trade, which relates to the manufacturers. It relates to the right to property and the rights to individual consumers. They have the right to privacy, dignity, and bodily and psychological integrity as well.

Michael  Evans, Public Law Partner - Webber Wentzel

They're allowed to smoke cannabis at home, but effectively they're not allowed to smoke cigarettes because they can't purchase them. We're saying that those rights have been infringed by this ban.

Michael  Evans, Public Law Partner - Webber Wentzel

Cost vs Benefit

In addition, the applicants will debate whether the supposed health benefits of the ban have outweighed the harm caused by the prohibition.

Evans says the economic damage of the tobacco ban far outweighs the desired goal of reducing severe Covid-19 infections.

He says there has been "minimal gain" for the public health system.

Therefore, the applicants will argue that the government's ban does not meet the requirements of reasonableness and proportionality.

RELATED: More smokers sharing 'skyfs' and cigarette prices up by nearly 250%, study finds

The issue is whether if you stop smoking, you lessen the impact on the public health system.

Michael  Evans, Public Law Partner - Webber Wentzel

Based on the minister's own figures, we've said that 16 beds would be saved. In other words, by stopping smoking, the [Cogta] minister will free up 16 ICU beds in South Africa at any one point in time out of about 3,500 to 4,000 beds in SA.

Michael  Evans, Public Law Partner - Webber Wentzel

We've said that that is absolutely a minimal gain for this ban on smoking. Because against that, what you have is a massive impact on society. The entire tobacco industry has been affected, not just big manufacturers like BAT SA.

Michael  Evans, Public Law Partner - Webber Wentzel

There's no evidence that stopping smoking has had a massive impact in terms of the saving of beds.

Michael  Evans, Public Law Partner - Webber Wentzel

Evans says it may take several weeks before a court judgment is made in the matter.

Listen to the discussion on Weekend Breakfast with Sara-Jayne King:


2 August 2020 10:42 AM
Tags:
British American Tobacco
BAT SA
cigarette ban
Tobacco Ban
Minister Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma
court battle

More from Business

Gilbert rugby ball

It’s official! Rugby is coming back to South Africa - possibly to Nelspruit only

7 August 2020 3:09 PM

It’s possible that all the games will take place in Nelspruit, says IOL sports editor John Goliath.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Drinking driving keys whisky whiskey brandy drunk diu 123rf

'Nothing fishy about R600K Range Rover deposit. It was owed to me for alcohol'

7 August 2020 10:25 AM

Thabane Zulu (former DG, Human Settlements) reluctantly testified before the Zondo commission on Thursday, says eNCA’s Erin Bates.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

performance-3202707-1920jpg

Nigerian Afrobeats star aims to raise $20m to fund the continent's musicians

6 August 2020 9:03 PM

'Mr Eazi' launched the Africa Music Fund to support the continent's creative talent. Bruce Whitfield interviews Lee Kasumba.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

oranges-1117628-1920jpg

Good news for local citrus industry: Bumper season expected for US exports

6 August 2020 8:38 PM

Justin Chadwick (Citrus Growers' Association) says it's all thanks to the perceived immune-boosting attraction of Vitamin C.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

liquor-store-sales-wine-champagne-mmc-brut-bubbly-alcohol-booze-drinking-123rf

Former Shoprite CEO joins court battle against alcohol ban - Govt is too slow!

6 August 2020 7:36 PM

Bruce Whitfield interviews Whitey Basson, who believes it's just not good enough for govt to say ban will be lifted but not when.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

MTN-cellphone-network-service-provider-data-airtime-calls-123rf

MTN to quit Middle East to focus on Africa

6 August 2020 6:55 PM

Bruce Whitfield talks to MTN CFO Ralph Mupita about the reasons for the move and the company's huge profit increase.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

20200425ndzonlevel4jpg

Despairing wine farmers to battle Nkosazana Dlamini Zuma in court on 18 August

6 August 2020 2:30 PM

"It’s not rational to allow packed taxis, but not a glass of wine in a controlled environment," says Francois Rossouw.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

samsungjpg

In the market for a new cellphone? Here's one that costs as much as a used car!

6 August 2020 12:32 PM

Samsung's latest offering, the Galaxy Note20 smartphone, goes on sale in South Africa on 21 August as Kieno Kammies finds out...

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

scz-0623jpg

Bantu Holomisa has an idea to remove ANC 'thieves' from power before 2024

6 August 2020 9:36 AM

"If I was President Cyril Ramaphosa, I would take these suggestions seriously," says the UDM leader Bantu Holomisa.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

afrika-tikkunjpg

SA needs 'the Madiba compassion' more than ever now, says Afrika Tikkun CEO

5 August 2020 8:54 PM

Marc Lubner on the NGO's programmes for young South Africans and how working with Nelson Mandela inspired his life's work.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

More from Politics

Boy Mamabolo

ANC MP Boy Mamabolo issues apology to Sunday World journalist

8 August 2020 12:54 PM

ANC MP Boy Mamabolo has now apologised for his conduct after he threatened a Sunday World journalist during a recorded interview.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

190715-winde-edjpg

[WATCH] Alcohol sales should be allowed in the Western Cape, says Premier Winde

7 August 2020 6:28 PM

Premier Alan Winde says he's pushing for the alcohol ban to be lifted in the province.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Mugabe and Mbeki.jpg

'Zimbabweans sceptical as past envoys in Mbeki, Mugabe era used as a whitewash'

7 August 2020 1:37 PM

Human rights lawyer in Zimbabwe Douglas Coultart says hopefully the envoy will take a positive stance for the people of Zimbabwe.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

200316 Interministerial5

Covid-19 committee to gauge and report 'systemic flaws' in govt procurement

7 August 2020 1:19 PM

The inter-ministerial committee appointed by President Cyril Ramaphosa is expected to assess the trends linked to Covid-19 tenders across various governemt departments.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

mask-child-boy-learner-pupil-class-classroom-Covid-19-teaching-school-123rf

Send kids back to school, it’s safer for them there - SA Paediatric Association

7 August 2020 12:57 PM

"Covid-19 is going to be with us for years. On balance, it’s better for kids to be in school," says Prof Mignon McCulloch.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Media photographer press journalist journalism 123rf

SA media groups pressure SA govt to intervene in Zimbabwe's attack on journos

7 August 2020 12:50 PM

Media Monitoring South Africa, along with a number of other freedom of expression groups wrote to President Cyril Ramaphosa.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Drinking driving keys whisky whiskey brandy drunk diu 123rf

'Nothing fishy about R600K Range Rover deposit. It was owed to me for alcohol'

7 August 2020 10:25 AM

Thabane Zulu (former DG, Human Settlements) reluctantly testified before the Zondo commission on Thursday, says eNCA’s Erin Bates.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Zimbabwe flag 123rf

SA envoy to Zimbabwe after 'eerie silence from South African government' - DA

7 August 2020 8:27 AM

Ramaphosa is no stranger to the players involved and therefore well-placed to have taken action sooner, suggests DA's Bergman.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

traffic lights vandalised Jakes Gerwel Drive 2016

Traffic light battery theft during lockdown cost City of Cape Town R6.5 million

7 August 2020 7:19 AM

City 's Transport Mayco member Felicity Purchase says replacing infrastructure instead of providing more services is a tragedy.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

liquor-store-sales-wine-champagne-mmc-brut-bubbly-alcohol-booze-drinking-123rf

Former Shoprite CEO joins court battle against alcohol ban - Govt is too slow!

6 August 2020 7:36 PM

Bruce Whitfield interviews Whitey Basson, who believes it's just not good enough for govt to say ban will be lifted but not when.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward