Streaming issues? Report here
John Maytham 2019 1500 BW John Maytham 2019 1500 BW
Afternoon Drive with John Maytham
15:00 - 18:00
volume_up
volume_mute

Up Next: The Money Show with Bruce Whitfield
See full line-up
Afternoon Drive with John Maytham
15:00 - 18:00
Home
arrow_forward
Business
fiber_manual_record
Politics

British American Tobacco SA prepares for court showdown with govt on Wednesday

2 August 2020 10:42 AM
Tags:
British American Tobacco
BAT SA
cigarette ban
Tobacco Ban
Minister Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma
court battle

British American Tobacco SA (BAT SA) will be challenging the constitutionality of the tobacco ban in the Western Cape High Court.

The tobacco firm, which produces Dunhill and Lucky Strike, is one of 10 applicants set to jointly challenge the ban in court this Wednesday.

Tobacco farmers, manufacturers, and retailers are among other members of the industry joining the court bid.

The government defeated an earlier court challenge to unban cigarettes from the Fair Trade Independent Tobacco Association (Fita) in June.

RELATED: High Court dismisses Fita's legal bid to have cigarette ban overturned

Mike Evans, the lawyer representing BAT SA and others, says this legal application is not the same as Fita's failed bid.

Evans explains the crux of the legal arguments to CapeTalk host Sara-Jayne King.

Constitutionality

The applicants will argue that the tobacco ban infringes on various Constitutional rights, including the right to trade and the individual right to bodily integrity.

Evans says it's irrational that smokers are effectively prohibited from smoking cigarettes, but "they're allowed to smoke cannabis at home."

RELATED: Black tobacco farmers: We pay tax and create jobs, but SA govt is suppressing us

We've raised a series of Constitutional challenges saying that this ban infringes on a whole number of Constitutional rights.

Michael  Evans, Public Law Partner - Webber Wentzel

It infringes the right to trade, which relates to the manufacturers. It relates to the right to property and the rights to individual consumers. They have the right to privacy, dignity, and bodily and psychological integrity as well.

Michael  Evans, Public Law Partner - Webber Wentzel

They're allowed to smoke cannabis at home, but effectively they're not allowed to smoke cigarettes because they can't purchase them. We're saying that those rights have been infringed by this ban.

Michael  Evans, Public Law Partner - Webber Wentzel

Cost vs Benefit

In addition, the applicants will debate whether the supposed health benefits of the ban have outweighed the harm caused by the prohibition.

Evans says the economic damage of the tobacco ban far outweighs the desired goal of reducing severe Covid-19 infections.

He says there has been "minimal gain" for the public health system.

Therefore, the applicants will argue that the government's ban does not meet the requirements of reasonableness and proportionality.

RELATED: More smokers sharing 'skyfs' and cigarette prices up by nearly 250%, study finds

The issue is whether if you stop smoking, you lessen the impact on the public health system.

Michael  Evans, Public Law Partner - Webber Wentzel

Based on the minister's own figures, we've said that 16 beds would be saved. In other words, by stopping smoking, the [Cogta] minister will free up 16 ICU beds in South Africa at any one point in time out of about 3,500 to 4,000 beds in SA.

Michael  Evans, Public Law Partner - Webber Wentzel

We've said that that is absolutely a minimal gain for this ban on smoking. Because against that, what you have is a massive impact on society. The entire tobacco industry has been affected, not just big manufacturers like BAT SA.

Michael  Evans, Public Law Partner - Webber Wentzel

There's no evidence that stopping smoking has had a massive impact in terms of the saving of beds.

Michael  Evans, Public Law Partner - Webber Wentzel

Evans says it may take several weeks before a court judgment is made in the matter.

Listen to the discussion on Weekend Breakfast with Sara-Jayne King:




2 August 2020 10:42 AM
Tags:
British American Tobacco
BAT SA
cigarette ban
Tobacco Ban
Minister Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma
court battle

More from Business

Taxi industry paid only R5m in income taxes – its revenues total almost R90bn

12 May 2021 3:13 PM

The taxi industry pays "basically nothing" in income taxes, says Geordin Hill-Lewis, Shadow Minister of Finance at the DA.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

'We will shut them down' - Undertakers threaten to close Home Affairs offices

12 May 2021 2:23 PM

Funeral undertakers have threatened to intensify their protest action by bringing Home Affairs offices to a standstill across SA.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Pick n Pay owes customers R200m in unspent, soon-to-expire Smart Shopper points

12 May 2021 1:15 PM

Are you one of Pick n Pay’s 8.5m Smart Shopper card users? Spend your points or lose them, says the retailer's John Bradshaw.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

We are investigating almost half of what government spent - SIU

12 May 2021 12:40 PM

"It is very worrying," says Special Investigations Unit spokesperson Kaizer Kganyago.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Hawks bust R320 million tax fraud syndicate – recovers R44 million

12 May 2021 8:40 AM

"Twenty individuals collaborated with small business owners, claiming undue VAT refunds," says Captain Lloyd Ramhova (Hawks).

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

[WATCH] José Mourinho offers one-on-one 'confidence coaching' in Sanlam campaign

11 May 2021 9:04 PM

'In life, confidence is the game changer' says the ad. Who better to exemplify that than Mourinho - branding expert Andy Rice.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Microchip shortage: From phones to cars, everything's about to cost more

11 May 2021 8:28 PM

The Money Show's Bruce Whitfield interviews media analyst Arthur Goldstuck (MD, World Wide Worx).

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Govt to table new pay offer as Fitch warns public sector wage freeze unlikely

11 May 2021 7:38 PM

Bruce Whitfield interviews Nazmeera Moola (Head of SA Investments, Ninety One) as public wage negotiations take a new turn.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Timing of SA's 3rd wave crucial: 'Early wave probably less severe than 2nd wave'

11 May 2021 6:56 PM

The Actuarial Society of SA sketches 3 possible Covid scenarios. Bruce Whitfield interviews Adam Lowe (Covid-19 Working Group).

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Electric cars will be cheaper than 'normal' ones by 2027 - study

11 May 2021 2:08 PM

By 2035, all new cars sold in Europe could be electric, according to a study by Bloomberg New Energy Finance.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

More from Politics

'We had real heroes at Battle of Bangui that should have been celebrated'

12 May 2021 3:19 PM

Lester Kiewit talks to journalists Stephan Hoffstater and James Oatway, as well as Kele Bojane widow of Rifleman Motsamai Bojane.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Arms Deal Inquiry judges may face JSC probe over claims of whitewashing evidence

12 May 2021 1:50 PM

Arms Deal Inquiry judges may face allegations which, if substantiated, could lead to their impeachment, says Karyn Maughan.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Backlog of forensic DNA testing samples now sitting at over 208k

12 May 2021 10:20 AM

Police Minister Bheki Cele says he hopes the police forensic services will be functioning normally within 18 months.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Govt to table new pay offer as Fitch warns public sector wage freeze unlikely

11 May 2021 7:38 PM

Bruce Whitfield interviews Nazmeera Moola (Head of SA Investments, Ninety One) as public wage negotiations take a new turn.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Welgevonden resident disputes SPCA claim that duck culling was humane

11 May 2021 5:54 PM

Candice Johnson says the vet report shows ducks were fed bread with an unidentified toxin, also eaten by indigenous water birds.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Ace Magashule ordered to say sorry – will (can) he?

11 May 2021 12:38 PM

Mandy Wiener interviews Eyewitness News senior politics journalist Tshidi Madia.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

'Israeli settlers want to take over Palestinian homes in Jerusalem'

11 May 2021 9:26 AM

Na'eem Jennah, Executive Director at the Afro-Middle East Centre explains the roots of clashes in East Jerusalem.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

'Ace Magashule has been pushed and ANC NEC will rally behind that decision'

11 May 2021 7:52 AM

Political analyst Ralph Mathekga talks about decisions made at the three-day ANC NEC and the impact on the political landscape

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

Blaming homeless for fire-starting is discrimination, says former homeless man

11 May 2021 6:42 AM

Rehoming Collective's Carlos Mesquita explains why they gave refuge to Table Mountain fire suspect charged with infringing by-law.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward

ANC vs ANC: 'It is the defeat of the Radical Economic Transformation crowd'

10 May 2021 6:53 PM

The Money Show’s Bruce Whitfield interviews Lumkile Mondi, a senior lecturer at Wits School of Economics And Business Science.

Share this:
Read More arrow_forward