Where should the line be drawn for celebrities' right to privacy?
This week in the Talking Point on Weekend Breakfast, presenter Sara-Jayne King asks, to what extent should people in the public eye have a right to privacy?
The South African Editors forum (Sanef) this past week slammed media personality Somizi Mhlangu-Motaung after he posted to his 3.7 million followers on Instagram the telephone number of a journalist he claimed had invaded his privacy by messaging him to ask about rumours of his husband's infidelity and then later published, according to him a false article about the state of his marriage.
Included in the post was a caption encouraging his followers to call the journalist in question so that, quote "she knows what it feels like to have your privacy invaded unprovoked".
The journalist did indeed receive calls, with some threatening her with rape and harm to her family.
Somizi later apologised for posting the telephone number, but not for what he said was sticking up for himself
To what extent should those in the public eye have a right to privacy? Who was in the wrong both ethically and legally?
Sara-Jayne talks to law expert, Maushami Chetty, CEO at Aarya Legal to find out where the lines should be drawn.
Our right to privacy is enshrined in the Constitution...which includes the right not to have your home searched, your property seized, the privacy of your communications infringed.Maushami Chetty, CEO - Aarya Legal
But the right to privacy predates the Constitution, she notes.
We have a wealth of common law and case law on the right to privacy...which is still used to determine the extent of your privacy.Maushami Chetty, CEO - Aarya Legal
She says tactics used by journalists in the past have been challenged legally through case law.
How was the information obtained? Was it done through clandestine measures, or was it done by asking the person? Certainly, one of the journalistic ethics issues is to check your sources to try and confirm your story, which I believe the journalist in question did try to do.Maushami Chetty, CEO - Aarya Legal
Chetty says the real test for whether someone has a right to privacy for a particular piece of information has two components, a subjective part and an objective part.
1. Do you have a subjective expectation that you will have privacy regarding a particular piece of information?
2. Will society consider that objectively reasonable?
She says the subjective part deals with the legitimate expectation of privacy.
If you are a person in the public sphere, do you have an expectation of privacy if you have shared, for example, your marriage on Showmax?Maushami Chetty, CEO - Aarya Legal
Listen to the interview below:
Source : @somizi via instagram.com
The Cape Town singing star hosts this Sunday's edition of #AnHourWith, CapeTalk's special weekly music offering.Read More
The allegations have been made by an actress who claims the Oscar-nominated star raped her at her home three years ago.Read More
Lead actress Lea Vivier opens up about her experience filming the new Showmax original drama 'Dam', which premiers on Monday 22 Feb.Read More
ICYMI - CapeTalk's brightest junior and adult minds delivered two epic semi-final battles in their respective rounds.Read More
South African songstress Kelly Khumalo joins Sara-Jayne King to talk about her latest album, reality TV show, and her relationship with fame.Read More
John's 3 book picks this week.Read More
Africa Melane chats to Refilwe Moloto about the annual event that has had to shift gears due to the coronavirus pandemic.Read More
DJ Fresh slammed for calling rape accuser a 'pathological liar', family call on former 947 host to 'retract his false claims'.Read More
The original famous-for-being-famous "socialite" and "social media influencer" (apologies Kim Kardashian) is 40 years old.Read More
News editor and broadcaster is spinning her fave tracks on Sunday's #An HourWith special feature at 10am.Read More
'We owe a lot of people a lot of money' says Tito Mboweni. Wide-ranging reaction to Budget 2021 on The Money Show.Read More
All eyes were on South African Finance Minister Tito Mboweni as he delivers his 2021 Budget Speech on Wednesday at 2pm.Read More
Refilwe Moloto chats to Education strategy consultant Raees Khan and education law specialist Dr Jaco Deacon about matric results.Read More
Gqeberha is the isiXhosa name for Walmer Township, one of the first and oldest Port Elizabeth townships.Read More
Western Cape Education Department Senior Curriculum Planner: Life Orientation/Life Skills Ismail Teladia talks to Refilwe Moloto.Read More
Statistician-General Risenga Maluleke says easing lockdown regs will allow people to move from non-economically active category.Read More
The Environment, Forestry and Fisheries Minister is heading to the High Court to have the current fishing rights scrapped,Read More
Umalusi head Prof Volmink says results were not expected to go up this year, and the results are credible.Read More
Gift of the Givers has been trying to assist. Founder and chair, Imtiaz Sooliman says it is a crisis that has entered its sixth day.Read More
Andrea Rademeyer CEO & Founder of Ask Afrika discusses the results of the latest survey.Read More