I would never seek to influence Chief Justice - Gordhan on meeting with Mogoeng
In a letter addressed to the Judicial Service Commission (JSC), Gordhan has denied ever influencing Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng.
Public Enterprises Minister Pravin Gordhan’s letter to the Judicial Service Commission:— Karyn Maughan (@karynmaughan) April 14, 2021
“I want to state emphatically that I would never, and nor did I in any way, seek to influence the Chief Justice, whose independence I have always respected.” pic.twitter.com/AElwnBezpj
On Tuesday, Mogoeng revealed that Gordhan had met with him five years ago and asked about the performance of his close friend Judge Dhaya Pillay who was seeking a position at the Supreme Court of Appeal at the time.
The Chief Justice made the claim while grilling Pillay during interviews for Constitutional Court judge candidates.
However, Gordhan says the meeting with Mogoeng, which took place in April 2016, was not held to discuss judge Pillay's interview with the JSC.
Gordhan, who was Finance Minister at the time, says his reference to judge Pillay during his 2016 meeting with Mogoeng was “purely incidental”.
Part 2 pic.twitter.com/0519ZPTTAx— Lukhanyo Vangqa (@LukhanyoV) April 13, 2021
Lawson Naidoo, the executive secretary of Casac, says Mogoeng's comments seem spurious in the context of the interview.
According to Naidoo, there are no legitimate allegations that Gordhan tried to sway Mogoeng in any way because it was already known at that time that Pillay didn't get the job.
"One needs to be careful about making political allegations against a candidate judge without any evidence to back that up", Naidooo tells CapeTalk.
It seems to be a spurious issue to have raised in the interview of judge Pillay.Lawson Naidoo, Executive secretary - Casac
JSC practices indicate that if such a question would be put to a candidate, they should be forewarned so that they can prepare an adequate response. The Chief Justice seems to have parted ways with the accepted practice of the JSC in posing such a question.Lawson Naidoo, Executive secretary - Casac
The fact that Minister Gordhan made that comment was certainly unwise of him to do so but it does not evince any intention on the part of Mr Gordhan to seek to influence the outcome in any way.Lawson Naidoo, Executive secretary - Casac
Having asked the question and received the response from the Chief Justice that judge Pillay was unsuccessful, there is no allegation that Mr. Gordhan then sought to try and influence the Chief Justice in any way.Lawson Naidoo, Executive secretary - Casac
In his statement today, Minister Gordhan hs made it clear that this was a substantive meeting about various issues, he cannot recollect which one but he gives a list of issues that he would have engaged with the Chief Justice on at the time, including the renewal of the term of appointment of the Tax Ombudsman.Lawson Naidoo, Executive secretary - Casac
Listen to the discussion on Afternoon Drive with John Maytham:
Source : Cindy Archillies/EWN
Pippa Hudson talks to Table Mountain National Park's manager, Frans Van Rooyen, and lobby group Parkscape chair Nicky Schmidt.Read More
Zuma's legal team says it wants to bring a special plea to remove NPA Advocate Billy Downer from the prosecution.Read More
CapeTalk caller Clive says the gate is chained and people are climbing the fence and crossing the tracks which is very dangerous.Read More
Sascoc President Barry Hendricks says sport should belong to civil society.Read More
Baboon Matters founder Jenni Trethowan says 'it feels like the City is stamping its foot, saying see what happens next.'Read More
Got a question for Facebook? Contact DA Member of Parliament Phumzile Van Damme of the Communications portfolio committee.Read More
Suspended ANC SG Ace Magashule has launched legal action against the ANC to challenge the constitutionality of the “step aside” rule that led to his suspension last week.Read More
WCHD urges the public not to queue at venues until they register and receive a follow-up SMS confirming the time, date, and venue.Read More
Suspended ANC secretary-general Ace Magashule is seen throwing a few quick jabs at a punching bag in a video posted by the EFF's Julius Malema.Read More
"It was a real battle to get those monies paid over. It required real doggedness," says Nicole Fritz of Freedom Under Law.Read More