Banking ombud probing how thieves stole over R200k from woman's 'blocked' phone
A woman had her cellphone stolen in the Sandton area and then discovered that her bank accounts had been cleared via her banking app - despite blocking her SIM card with her network service provider.
The one thing to take out from all of this: If your phone is stolen or missing, the first call you must make is to your bank, if you have a banking app on your phone.Wendy Knowler, consumer journalist
Joburg resident Cara Anderson had her phone stolen from her at store at Fourways Mall in August this year.
Within 30 minutes of the theft, she contacted Vodacom asking them to blacklist the phone and block the SIM.
She says the consultant confirmed that there was “no access to her device”.
However, two hours later her bank account was raided with the use of one-time pins (OTPs) sent to the phone which had supposedly been blocked.
Thieves helped themselves to over R200 000 in a series of transactions between 5pm and 7am the next day.
Because she thought she had disabled the SIM card with Vodacom, Anderson says she did not see the need to block her bank account at the time.
She says her phone had multiple security passwords and a facial recognition unlocking mechanism.
Despite this, all her money was stolen and she was left with R42 in her account.
Bank refuses to pay up or show proof
Anderson has lodged a complaint with the Ombudsman for Banking Services, which is currently investigating the matter.
The bank has refused to reimburse her because it claims that the criminals must have had access to her banking passwords stored on her device.
Anderson has denied this.
At no point have I ever stored any passwords for the banking app on my device.Cara Anderson
The bank involved will only be named once the Ombud has made a ruling in the investigation.
Anderson also claims that the bank's fraud department did not contact her or flag any unusual activity on her account, despite several large transactions, one of which was R130,000.
She adds that the bank has not provided her with any evidence of the transactions or proof of the claim that her passwords were not secured.
Vodacom 'SIM blocking' protocol questioned
Anderson says that three different consultants from Vodacom acknowledged via phone calls that a "hard lock" should have been implemented on her device.
However, once they realised that she had R200,000 stolen, they apparently changed their tune and said their Standard Operating Procedure was a "soft lock", which only prevents outgoing calls.
The phone was off. I phoned Vodacom immediately and they blocked the SIM. When it's blocked then fraudsters can't get into your device, they might as well throw it away, that was our discussion.Cara Anderson
The consultant on the phone said there is no access to my device... So I actually relaxed, it was only the following day when I realised my bank accounts had been cleared out.Cara Anderson
Nobody ever declared that there was a soft lock in place and that they only protect themselves in terms of outgoing calls so that nobody racks up the phone bill which will have to cover.Cara Anderson
They don't tell you that they do not block incoming calls. So the fraudsters hacked my phone, they passed facial recognition, passed my password, managed to hack pass the banking app - which the bank still denies.Cara Anderson
Listen to the discussion on ConsumerTalk with Wendy Knowler:
Every Wednesday, on Lunch with Pippa Hudson, Wendy Knowler provides useful insights and tips on how to make the most of your buying power.
For more stories visit the ConsumerTalk feature page.
Got a consumer case you need help resolving?
Email: firstname.lastname@example.org, put Cape Talk in the subject line, followed by the issue e.g. cellphone contract dispute.
Source : https://www.123rf.com/photo_100039538_young-women-shopping-online-on-smartphone-business-and-modern-lifestyle-concept.html
Impersonation fraud has increased by a massive 337%. Consumers have been warned to protect their personal information.Read More
Lay-by allows you to choose an item and then pay it off every month, interest-free, explains consumer journalist Wendy Knowler.Read More
A financial expert has warned locals not to fall for a pyramid scheme known as Divine Prosperity Blossom that has sprung up in Cape Town.Read More
Heather John says she was not paid for a guest booking at her holiday apartment but MD apologises and she has now been paid.Read More
Covid-19 restrictions around the world have led to the huge popularity of online supermarket shopping, but there's a catch.Read More
ConsumerTalk consumer journalist Wendy Knowler says the 'basket of goods' comparison has a number of flaws.Read More
A Cape Town woman has been left with serious lung damage after her ozone therapy session went wrong. A medical doctor weighs in.Read More
Unwanted charges on your cell bill? Struggling to unsubscribe from rogue content services that you never signed up for? Here's what you can do.Read More
Hand sanitiser has become a highly sought-after product amid the coronavirus pandemic. But are all of them effective? Wendy Knowler investigates.Read More
Wendy Knowler, Consumer Ninja, investigates non-payment of business interruption claims during the Covid-19 lockdown.Read More